Investment strategies
Investment Strategies
An investment strategy is a set of rules for what you buy, when you buy and sell it, and how much of your money goes into each holding. Having one, and writing it down, is the best defence against the commonest investor mistakes: buying on tips, selling in panic, and drifting into a portfolio you never chose.
There is no single right strategy. The best one for you depends on your goals and time horizon, how much risk you can bear, how much time and skill you bring, and your temperament. A strategy you will stick with through a bad year beats a cleverer one you will abandon.
This page links to articles by ShareSoc directors and members on particular topics. It then outlines the main strategy types, how to monitor your results, and where to find investment ideas.
Bull and Bear Markets
In this article, ShareSoc Director Ram Sachdev explains “bull” and “bear” markets and how they arise. He also suggests how they may affect your investment strategy.
What are Bull and Bear Markets?
DIY Investing vs Using a Financial Adviser
Costs compound just as returns do, so the way you pay for investment management matters. ShareSoc member Cliff Weight compared two routes for a £170,000 portfolio, roughly the average portfolio of a St James’s Place client. A Vanguard passive fund held on interactive investor cost about £300 a year. Advice from one of the UK’s leading firms of advisers cost about £3,400 a year. Charging structures change, so treat the figures as illustrative, but the scale of the gap is the point. Read Cliff’s analysis of what advice really costs.
Passive vs Active Investment
For many investors, a “passive” approach may well be the best option. That applies especially to those without the time or inclination to research investments in depth. In this article, ShareSoc member Cliff Weight weighs active against passive investment and explains how to put either into practice.
Understanding Investment Trusts
Paul Greenwood, a member of the ShareSoc Policy & Campaigns Committee, has written a comprehensive guide to investment trusts. It covers:
- the closed-ended structure, and how trusts compare with OEICs and ETFs;
- the role of the independent board;
- gearing and income smoothing; and
- why discounts matter, including how to read a discount as a buy signal.
For a closer look at discounts, this AJ Bell article explains why they arise and what they can tell you. It also explains why the size of a discount alone should not decide whether a trust is attractive.
Strategy Types: Matching Your Approach to Your Requirements, Skills and Personality
Before choosing a style, answer four questions honestly:
- What is the money for, and when will you need it? Money needed within about five years should not depend on the stock market.
- Do you need income now, or growth for later?
- How much time and skill will you put in? Reading annual reports and following companies takes hours each week. An index fund takes minutes each year.
- How will you react to a 30% fall? Most investors overestimate their tolerance until they experience one.
The main stock-picking styles below are not mutually exclusive. Many successful private investors blend two or three of them.
| Style | What it looks for | Typical measures | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Value | Shares priced below what the business is worth | Low price/earnings (P/E), price/book or EV/EBITDA; high free-cash-flow yield | “Value traps”: shares that are cheap because the business is declining |
| Growth | Companies growing sales and profits fast | Revenue and earnings growth, return on capital, market opportunity | Paying too much: high expectations leave little room for disappointment |
| Quality and GARP (“growth at a reasonable price”) | Durable, highly profitable businesses at sensible prices | High and stable return on capital, strong balance sheet, PEG ratio | Overpaying for quality that is already widely recognised |
| Income | Reliable and rising dividends | Dividend yield, dividend cover, payout history | Chasing high yields that are about to be cut |
| Momentum | Shares already rising, with improving news | Relative price strength, earnings upgrades | Sharp reversals; high turnover and dealing costs |
Value
Value investors buy shares for less than their estimate of the underlying business’s worth, keeping a “margin of safety” against mistakes. The approach, set out by Benjamin Graham and practised by Warren Buffett, needs patience. Cheap shares can stay cheap for years, and value investing has had long spells of underperformance.
Growth
Growth investors pay up for companies expanding rapidly, betting that future profits will justify today’s price. Smaller companies, including those on AIM, offer the most growth opportunities but also the most failures. Diversification and position sizing matter more here than in any other style.
Income
Income investors focus on dividends, either to live on or to reinvest. Reinvested dividends have historically provided a large share of the stock market’s long-run total return.
A high yield is often a warning, not a bargain, because it frequently signals that the market expects a cut. Check that earnings and cash flow cover the dividend comfortably. Spread income across sectors, since a few large companies often account for much of the UK market’s dividends. Investment trusts can help smooth income, as they may hold back reserves in good years to pay dividends in bad ones.
The split between income and capital gains also matters for tax outside an ISA or pension. Dividends and gains are taxed differently, and the allowance for each is small.
Asset Allocation
Asset allocation is how you divide your money between asset classes, such as shares, bonds, cash and property, and between regions and sectors. It probably matters more to your long-run outcome than which individual shares you pick, because it largely sets both your expected return and how bumpy the ride will be.
Some principles:
- Diversify, but not without limit. Twenty or so shares across different sectors removes most company-specific risk. Beyond that, extra holdings add little protection and take more time to follow.
- Size positions deliberately. Decide in advance the most you will put into any one share. Many private investors cap this at 5–10% of the portfolio, and at less for speculative holdings.
- Look beyond the UK. The UK is a small part of world stock markets, and the FTSE 100 is concentrated in a few sectors. A global index fund or investment trust is a simple way to add overseas exposure.
- Match risk to time horizon. The longer before you need the money, the more you can hold in shares. As a goal approaches, shifting gradually towards gilts and cash reduces the chance that a market fall derails it.
- Rebalance. Over time, the assets that have done well grow to dominate. Restoring your target mix once a year, or when an allocation drifts by more than an agreed margin, forces you to sell high and buy low.
A “core and satellite” approach suits many ShareSoc members. A low-cost index fund or a few global investment trusts form the core. Directly held shares, where your own research adds value, are the satellites.
Mechanical and Quantitative Strategies: Pros and Cons
A mechanical strategy picks shares by fixed rules rather than judgement. You might, for example, buy the 20 shares that rank best on a combined value and quality screen and replace them once a year. Well-known examples include Joel Greenblatt’s “Magic Formula”, Piotroski’s F-Score and the “Dogs of the Dow” high-yield approach. Several UK data services also publish rankings and model screens.
Advantages
- Rules remove emotion, which is the private investor’s greatest enemy.
- They are consistent, quick to apply and easy to review.
- Many are based on characteristics, such as value, quality and momentum, that academic research suggests have rewarded investors over long periods.
Disadvantages
- Backtests flatter. A rule that looks brilliant on past data may have been fitted to that data, or may stop working once widely known.
- Data is only as good as its source. Screens built on reported figures miss accounting problems that a careful reader of the annual report would catch.
- Discipline is harder than it sounds. Every strategy has bad years, and most investors abandon mechanical systems in exactly the years they should stick with them.
- Costs add up. Frequent rebalancing adds dealing costs and, outside an ISA, tax.
Many investors use a screen to generate ideas, then apply their own research before buying. That makes the most of both approaches.
Monitoring Results
Most private investors do not know their true return. Without knowing it, you cannot tell whether your strategy, and the time you spend on it, beats simply buying an index fund.
- Measure total return. Include dividends as well as price changes, and deduct all costs: dealing charges, platform fees and fund charges.
- Allow for money added and withdrawn. If you invest regularly, the portfolio’s growth flatters your performance. A spreadsheet’s XIRR function calculates your money-weighted annual return from the dates and amounts of each cash flow. Many platforms and portfolio-tracking services also report it.
- Compare against a fair benchmark. Use one that matches what you actually hold: for example, the FTSE All-Share total return index for a UK portfolio, or a global index fund for a mixed one. Judge over several years, not months.
- Keep an investment journal. For each purchase, record why you bought, what you expect to happen and what would make you sell. Reviewing it later shows whether your judgement or luck drove your results. It also helps you avoid rewriting history.
- Review on a schedule, not on headlines. A quarterly or half-yearly review, together with the company’s results announcements, is enough for most long-term investors. Checking prices daily mainly increases the temptation to overtrade.
- Have a sell discipline. Common reasons to sell are that the original reason for buying no longer holds, the shares have become clearly overvalued, a better use for the money has come along, or a position has grown too large. A fall in price alone is not a reason, though it is a prompt to re-check your reasoning.
If, after an honest three-to-five-year comparison, your own selections lag a low-cost index fund, consider moving more of your portfolio into passive investments. That is a strategy too.
Finding Investments
Ideas can come from anywhere. What matters is that you do your own checking before you buy.
Publications
Investment magazines, newsletters and the financial press are a steady source of ideas and commentary. Treat tips as a starting point for research, never as a reason to buy, and remember that a widely published tip may already be reflected in the price. See our list of periodicals and our recommended reading list.
Stock screeners
Screening tools filter the whole market for shares that meet your criteria, such as a low P/E ratio, high return on capital, rising dividends or low debt. They are the quickest way to put a chosen strategy into practice. See our guide to data sites and tools.
Fundamental analysis
Fundamental analysis means judging a company’s value from its business, finances and prospects. See our page on Fundamental Analysis, and on reading annual reports.
Investor presentations
Many listed companies, especially smaller ones, now present directly to private investors. They do so at ShareSoc seminars and webinars, at investor shows and on online presentation platforms. These events let you hear management and ask questions.
Remember that a presentation is a sales pitch. Judge management by the track record in their published accounts, not by the slides. See our upcoming events and Masterclasses.
Original research
The most valuable ideas usually come from your own work. That means reading company announcements and annual reports, attending AGMs, and noticing businesses that are doing well in everyday life or in your own industry. ShareSoc’s company research and AGM reports are useful starting points.
Digital media
Forums, podcasts, video channels and social media can give early insight and a range of views. They also give anonymous promoters a platform to “ramp” shares, so be sceptical of enthusiasm with no evidence behind it. Paid promotions are not always clearly labelled. Never act on urgency or on claims of guaranteed returns: see Investment Scams. For better-quality sources, see our lists of investment forums and educational videos, webcasts and podcasts.
This page is general education, not personal advice.